Welcome to Life as an Appraiser in 2014

AppraisersBlogs

AppraisersBlogs

AppraisersBlogs Team at AppraisersBlogs
Have questions or need help? Please contact us with any comments, questions or concerns.
AppraisersBlogs

Latest posts by AppraisersBlogs (see all)

Welcome to Life as an Appraiser in 2014

I  want  to meet the lucky appraiser these days who is getting all of the easy appraisals.

Welcome  to  life  as  an  appraiser  in  2014.  It  seems every  appraisal  has  time  constraints,  distance constraints  and  knowledge  constraints.  I  want  to meet the lucky appraiser these days who is getting all of the easy appraisals. Surely it can’t be lenders just getting an AVM. If lenders are using AVMs, the lack of quality comparables out there would lead to lenders just  fooling  themselves  and  relying  on  loss  ratios again.   You  would  think  someone  would  say:  been there, done that and got hammered. Unfortunately, some of the problems in the market with comparables are similar; mainly junk in, junk out. Another way of saying that would be: bad comparables in, then bad analysis out. In many of the market areas that I am in, it appears to have stabilized; however, these markets are still sluggish with few sales. We still don’t have the upward mobility in the market. The majority of people still don’t take the risk to sell their property and move to a larger home.  Even  the  standard,  arm’s  length, conventional sales appear to have some distressed background.

So if you do get a standard home to appraise, it becomes difficult to find the quality comparables to justify value. Get used to it, because our profession might be dealing with it for a long time. The only method of protection for the appraiser today is education and time to complete a quality appraisal. At some point in time the market will have to adjust and pay for the amount of professionalism and time to complete the assignments. The government has forced the appraiser to produce a better product, and somewhere down the line they will need to contemplate a cost/value analysis of the product they desire. I believe the scope of work has helped us out tremendously, and we as a profession have to become more proficient in utilizing the scope of work tools to complete work assignments in a competitive marketplace. A word of caution: make sure the client is clear in what they are asking for and receiving.

The three basic items to remember are:

  1. How do your peers complete appraisals?
  2. What do your lenders/government look for in a report?
  3. Is there a correct way to accomplish the appraisal? We definitely need more interaction among our peers to keep in tune with what’s going on.

In  reviewing  appraisals some of the main concerns are as follows:

  1. Neighborhood description
  2. Market analysis and condition
  3. Zoning
  4. History of sale
  5. Lot value

Obviously, there are some other items, such as crazy adjustments and condition adjustments; however, I’ll address a few of those items.

NEIGHBORHOOD DESCRIPTION

Many of the residential appraisers like to clone this section of the appraisal. Some portions of  this description might be able to be cloned. If you completed another appraisal in the subdivision, much of it could be cloned. I have trouble with this section not having real neighborhood discussion. Urban, suburb and rural generally would not have the same description. Does subject back to a highway or railroad and could that be a factor in the valuation of the property? We might see the same description in two appraisals in two separate cities or completely different type of neighborhoods. The style of homes that are in the area, site sizes, distance to commercial or interstate and industry in the community are important items in describing a neighborhood. Is subject near the median in value; if not, is there external depreciation possibly applicable? Does the subdivision have amenities such as a common lake, pool or golf course?   Is the subdivision compatible to the area, or is it an over-improvement? Again, this might or might not be an over-improvement for the area.At least discuss the neighborhood particulars.

MARKET ANALYSIS & CONDITION

I have to admit, I am not a fan of the market condition addendum. I believe most of the time we don’t have enough compatible properties to have a quality statistical analysis. The market area can be expanded so there are an ample number of compatible sales and listings, but variations in neighborhoods can distort the analysis.

The market condition addendum does not relieve the appraiser of the duty of developing some type of an analysis regarding a property’s market conditions. We usually do a year-to-year analysis of the overall market area to see if the median sale price has changed significantly. We also look at any considerable change in the days on the market and number of sales.

Other items we might discuss in a market analysis are the availability of funding, REO or short sales in the market. Some of this information can be cloned from appraisal to appraisal; however, with every report there is going to be new data for the market. Without doing some type of analysis, how can an appraiser state whether a market is inflating, stable, or declining? There have been market areas where no one is selling property. Some markets have only REO or short sales. Again, discuss this and describe why you believe this is a distressed market.

ZONING

Obviously zoning is an important issue. Single Family Residential might not be specific enough in the classification or the description. Most of the forms ask for a zoning classification, which might be R1, R2, etc. We are then asked to provide a description of that classification, such as single family residential, 10,000 square foot minimum site. The main issue with zoning may occur with older homes. If an older home is significantly damaged, the site’s zoning might not allow the same type of structure to be built or same usage of the property. Most zoning descriptions provide the minimum lot size allowable for the usage or structure. Most communities are on the internet with their zoning, and the appraiser is responsible for checking the site. If no website is available, you need to contact the municipality or county. Zoning of a commercial or multi-family property is imperative to developing highest and best use. If a commercial appraiser is not obtaining the correct zoning or making the hypothetical that the zoning is correct for the usage, this would be a major problem at the commission level. If your community is not making it easy to get zoning information, I suggest you become active and make it easy to get the information. There is no excuse if you just have “single family residential” under the classification when the governmental body has specific classifications.

SALE HISTORY

I realize some counties are nondisclosure; however, they all keep a record if the property has transferred. We are required to give a transfer history of the subject property and comparables. MLS will give us some information; however, research needs to come from the county records. It’s black and white. You either did it or didn’t do it. It is a violation by not having the information. It is a possibility that your county might not be up-to-date with the information, which is why they ask the date of the source. The larger counties give the date of the source on the internet. You might want to ask the assessor’s office how often they update. You’re only as good as your source. This is particularly true for a property that may have been “flipped.” I believe many lenders look for any excuse so they don’t have to take the blame for a bad loan. If a property has a large difference in the current sale price or refinance value and a previous sale price, you are supposed to explain the variation. The more description you provide, the better. Protect yourself. A thorough description is your best defense if a loan goes bad and the owner of the note wants to send the appraisal report to the commission. Incorrectly cloned information and a mostly generic description does not help; it only makes the appraisal more difficult to read.

LOT VALUE

Even if you are not doing a cost approach, you are still required to provide a land value. Most of the time, it would be difficult to complete a cost approach effectively if you did not complete an accurate lot valuation. A site valuation should benefit any necessary lot adjustments in the sales comparison approach. That being said, providing the assessor’s valuation of a site is not an appropriate method for site valuation. The assessor’s opinion on site value might be a good viewpoint if you have a quality assessor, but should only be a viewpoint. Many appraisals state you have completed an extraction approach. Have you really? Many of the lot values we see at the Commission level are ridiculous and have not been achieved by any approach. Go back three years and get some comparables. If there are only a few sales, you will probably use them over and over again. Document them in the appraisal with MLS numbers or sources of the sales information. Was the location and price point for the area similar, topography similar, utilities similar and size similar, and should there be a date of sale adjustment? If you’re in an area where homes are being razed to build larger homes, don’t just take 20–25% of the value and say it is the land value. If you see a newer home in an older, fully developed area, check as to what the original home or lot sold for. A property’s zoning, sale history and lot value are fundamentals for an appraisal report. The basics for an appraisal can be simple, and will help create a better report.

I believe appraisers will always be better than AVMs; however, lenders will continue to push for them because they are faster and cheaper. Putting too much emphasis on AVMs will get the lenders burnt again. It is my belief the best tool an appraiser can have is common sense. Naturally, education, sources and writing skills are necessary; however, the best guide is common sense. Know your limitations and act accordingly. If an appraisal assignment becomes too difficult, either get help or withdraw from the assignment.

By Darryl Knopf, Chair
~ Source Missouri Real Estate Appraisers Commission Newsletters – January 2014

Image credit flickr - Nathan
AppraisersBlogs

AppraisersBlogs

Have questions or need help? Please contact us with any comments, questions or concerns.

You may also like...

9 Responses

  1. Retired Appraiser Retired Appraiser says:

    Loved your quote: “I want to meet the lucky appraiser these days who is getting all of the easy appraisals”. Nice article BTW.

    My response: I would love to meet one residential appraiser that can justify the insanity of staying in this “profession”.

    Hint: “Because I have a family to feed doesn’t cut it”. If you truly cared about your family you would have moved them 10,000 miles away from the world of appraising five years ago.

    3

    0
  2. Bryan says:

    Great article! My only comment – going back 1, 2 or even 3 years looking for site sales in an established area will most likely not give you any validation. I do understand the point – make an effort to provide the best data available.

    3

    0
  3. Is any other appraiser frustrated with the timeliness of appraisals that include weekends and holidays? Numerous companies now order completion in “hours”. I received an appraisal on Friday afternoon and they “allowed” me 96 hours to submit report. Monday is a holiday and I will not inspect property until next business day after order so I am already late with assignment before I even start. When did we go on call 24/7 ????

    3

    0
  4. David Kennedy says:

    My dad was a Realtor, then a developer, then an appraiser. He, my mother and entire family worked seven days per week. The office was always open and clients always knew they could call and we would always be there. Nothing is changed. I’m now way past “retirement” age, and the office is always open. My clients still know that we are always available. If you don’t want to work that hard, then find another occupation. I pay no attention to holidays, Sundays, or any other day of the week. Try it. You’ll live.

    2

    1
    • Bryan says:

      I feel bad for David. He will look back and wonder what the H happened! We set our own schedule and that is what has kept me in this job for decades. I will contend – if you have to work seven days a week you have the wrong job. I will kick it 5 days a week. Occasional Saturday morning. I love my family too much for anything else! We walk, camp, cook on the grill, chill in the pool with friends in the summer, read in the winter, have our kids and grandkids over for Sunday morning breakfast……you know – live.

      4

      0
  5. AppraiserMorons says:

    That’s really sad David that you have unknowingly become the workhorse for your clients. While they are home on the weekends or on vacation, they know you are working like a dog so they can become rich. This is what has happened to the modern day appraiser. More work for less money. Do yourselves a favor and get out of this business as soon as possible. I did it and it’s the best thing that ever happened to me. I have a life now.

    3

    0
  6. John says:

    Ok, How to become a preferred appraiser??? What am I doing wrong??? If a bank moves AMC’s and your not on that one, then you join. How do you go about getting Business from these lenders??? It seems there many connections that I am not making to obtain business. Please let me know what I am doing wrong.

    Thanks

    2

    0
  7. Mike Allen says:

    For Jennifer Pearce, regarding time to complete. Jennifer, I used to be focused on that same issue but after much thought, I’ve kicked the habit. I normally get my reports done the same day or next day, after the inspection. When I accept the order and they ask for projected completion time, I look at my calendar and then add two days. When I get the inspection scheduled, THEN I re-enter the conclusion date. The lenders and AMCs that I work with never give me any problem. I base my work on a 48 hour turnaround, AFTER the inspection. None of my clients can argue with that turnaround time. And, they don’t . You control your calendar, manage it accordingly. It will be very rare that a client asks you to do it sooner and if so, give your reasons why your date is the most logical date.

    2

    0
  8. raymond says:

    hmmm……interesting comments. whatever happen to the appraisal rule that the appraiser in preparing his/her appraisal, reflect the actions of the buyers/sellers in the applicable market. Seems to me, like the appraiser (doing mortgage work) have evolved more into reflecting and/or meeting the needs of the lender/amc. Plus, pretty amazing that anyone loves appraising so much that they would give up, their personal lives for appraising. It certainly can’t be for the $s.

    2

    0

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

xml sitemap

Welcome to Life as an Appraiser in 2014

by AppraisersBlogs time to read: 7 min
9