Appraiser Miller Wins
Appraiser Miller wins important claim in racial discrimination lawsuit. Judge ruled Plaintiffs did not rely on Miller’s appraisal. The other claims continue but this was an important claim. It also shows the Plaintiffs lied to the Court.
Plaintiffs purchased the house on 12/13/2016 at $550,000 from a black family, who had a preference to sell their house to someone of like race and carried out this sale off-market. Post-purchase, 270 square feet of living space was added to the ground level, and the house was renovated. The Austins had an appraisal performed, before the renovation and addition, which came in at $889,000. Appraiser Miller, hired by appraisal services company AMC Links, performed an appraisal in January 2020 which came in at $995,500. Since Appraiser Miller’s appraisal was not high enough for the Austins to achieve their objective, they complained to the lender and another appraisal was ordered. The Austins had a white friend stage their house to appear owned by a white person, and the second appraiser was met for the inspection and informed about the cost of additions and renovations at approximately $400,000. The second appraisal came in at $1,482,500, $487,000 more than Miller’s.
You can follow Mary Cummins blog for up-to-date information for the case.
- Appraisers Pressured to Inflate Values Based on Race - August 16, 2023
- Foregoing Contingencies! But What About Fiduciary Duty? - June 27, 2023
- NAR Concerns & Survey on Property Data Collectors - June 5, 2023