Consumer Involvement with Property Value
“Help” the consumer determine a value
There is a little known provision in the new TRID mortgage loan application process that may become a future issue for appraisers, especially when the loan is for a Refinance.
This is what the Loan Estimate, provided by the lender, requires the CONSUMER to do:
You (the lender) must provide a Loan Estimate to the consumer, either by delivering by hand or placing in the mail, no later than three business days of the receipt of an application. An application is considered received when the consumer provides the following information:
- Consumer’s name,
- Consumer’s income,
- Consumer’s Social Security number to obtain a credit report,
- Address of the property,
- Estimate of the value of the property, and
- The mortgage loan amount sought.
While this may seem innocuous, it could, in time, bite appraisers in the behind.
Why? Because CONSUMERS have been known to take exception to appraised values. Especially when the consumer has an overly extended, emotionally tied, ‘number’ fixated in their noggin.
These kinds of consumers have been known to file formal state regulator complaints against appraisers, claiming improper value. Taken to the extreme, lawsuits have been filed alleging misconduct or misfeasance on the part of the appraiser.
Back in the old days, pre-TRID Oct 2015, the loan officers would try to determine a ‘number’ to shoot for, for the refinance loan. But this was informal, and not ‘required’ as the present application mandates.
The other hidden aspect of this Loan Estimate regulation is the potential for the loan officers to “help” the consumer determine a value. We appraisers won’t know if that assistance has been given, and it likely won’t be something the loan officer will reveal in their file. But with all the on-line valuation services available, it’s not inconceivable that this will happen.
We won’t, or shouldn’t, be given this ‘presumed value’ at the time of assignment. But, again, if it’s way out of line, we appraisers may get challenged.
There is nothing “we” can do about this Loan Estimate situation.
What we can do is be extremely careful when establishing our Opinion of Value for properties. Make sure you do proper due diligence and research to validate your decision. Document everything. Keep a proper and complete workfile.
Let’s be careful out there!
- Mortgage Application Volume Nearing Historic Low - September 22, 2023
- The Unbiased Reality of Census Tract Data Dump… Open Letter to FHFA - August 15, 2023
- Isn’t that Just PAVEY! PAVE Response and Marcia Fudge - August 8, 2023