Appraiser Independence Requirements - Appraisers Blogs

Appraiser Independence: What Does it Mean & Who Does it Apply to

Guest Author — Mon, 31 Aug 2026 12:30:57 +0000

Why It Matters Appraiser independence is mandated by state and federal laws – not a professional courtesy. Every agent, broker, loan officer, lender and AMC involved in a transaction with a lender-ordered appraisal is legally prohibited from influencing the appraiser’s value conclusion and from interfering in the appraisal process. Violations can cost you your license, trigger federal civil penalties, NAR sanctions, civil liability, and in extreme cases, criminal prosecution.1 “I didn’t know” is not a defense. The Legal Foundation Three federal frameworks govern this area. Title XI of FIRREA (1989) requires all appraisals for federally related transactions to be performed...

Violating Appraisal Independence Through Harassment,… It shall be unlawful... to engage in any act or practice that violates appraisal independence... Appraisers, I have written the…
No I Won't Work With This Appraiser How much power do agents have over the appraisal process? The lender gets a call. Agent tells them that appraiser…
Expert Wants to “Eliminate” Appraisers Mortgage Industry Expert Wants to “Eliminate” Appraisers – A Response The National Mortgage News website just published an interview with…

The post Appraiser Independence: What Does it Mean & Who Does it Apply to appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

Appraisers Pressured to Inflate Values Based on Race

AppraisersBlogs — Wed, 16 Aug 2023 12:30:12 +0000

The real estate appraisal industry has long been subject to pressure from various sources, such as lenders, borrowers, and agents. In the past, this pressure often came in the form of withholding business if appraisers refused to inflate values, or ignore property deficiencies. Nowadays, it appears that government efforts, aimed at curbing discrimination, are actually leading to increased pressure on appraisers to inflate values. This is a troubling development for honest appraisers who may be feeling more pressured than ever before by those looking for higher numbers than what an accurate appraisal would yield. Unfortunately, some have taken this opportunity...

The New & Improved Fannie Mae “FRAUDULATOR 2.0” Originally known as Fannie Mae’s Collateral Underwriter (CU), and subsequently Collateral Underwriter 2.0 (CU-2)i this always dubious product of Fannie…
The Town With No Bank: How Rural America Lost Its… For decades, we’ve been told that the problem is demand. That people don’t want to live in rural America anymore.…
The Real Cause of the Home Value Gap Is the Income Gap Blaming appraisers for the income gap will never solve the real underlying problem... Blaming appraisers for the income gap is…

The post Appraisers Pressured to Inflate Values Based on Race appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

VA Appraisal Request Form at Heart of AIR Violation Class Action

Peter Christensen — Tue, 23 May 2023 12:30:52 +0000

While the statute doesn’t explicitly mention that providing a loan amount is an AIR violation… When a mortgage lender seeks to make a Veterans Administration-backed home loan, the lender requests an appraisal from the VA’s appraiser panel by using a form entitled Request for Determination of Reasonable Value. For many years, until it was revised in July 2022, this form had a box labelled “Refinancing-Amount of Proposed Loan.” This box asked the lender to fill in the proposed loan amount for refinances. Once submitted, the form begins the appraisal process and is provided to the appraiser assigned by the VA...

Proposal to Eliminate the VA Fee Panel VA Fee Panel - The Appraisal Institute does not believe that a move to a lender select program, such as…
Slow VA Appraisal Turnaround Times Is Overblown Concerns about slow VA appraisal turnaround times is overblown... On September 14, 2022, US House passed HR 7735, "the Improving…
Appraisal Independence Most appraisers could care less about an amc score card... Professionals don’t treat other professionals like they are in grade…

The post VA Appraisal Request Form at Heart of AIR Violation Class Action appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

Fastapp AMC Alleged Violations of AIR

AppraisersBlogs — Wed, 01 Feb 2023 13:30:55 +0000

The following court documents in the case Naftali Horowitz v. [xxx], Fastapp AMC founder v. Fastapp AMC president, confirm what appraisers have been saying all along, that if you want high-volume AMC work, you have to lower your fees to 1980’s level, have 24 hour turn times, and, above all, be a number hitter. Horowitz, Fastapp founder, filed a lawsuit in New York court on January 31, 2022 against defendant to, among other things, remove the defendant as an officer and director of the Company because, when he brought her on as shareholder in 2020, he claimed that she made...

Violating Appraisal Independence Through Harassment,… It shall be unlawful... to engage in any act or practice that violates appraisal independence... Appraisers, I have written the…
Influencing the Appraiser The AMC control over the appraiser and the content of the appraisal report... The biggest issue that threatens the appraisers…
A Low Appraisal is Now a Bad Appraisal A low appraisal is now a bad appraisal. Well, that's according to the headline. The article does not stress ‘bad.’…

The post Fastapp AMC Alleged Violations of AIR appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

Diatribes Against Appraisers

Dave Towne — Mon, 31 Oct 2022 12:30:39 +0000

What’s even more frustrating to me is none of the well-known appraiser organizations have offered any public rebuttal to any of these hit pieces, or explained how the appraisal process works as a way to defend appraisers… Census Tract data delineating RACE of the population is the only ammunition the people doing these hit pieces can use to attack appraisers. Appraisers, this is a long article but it’s important, as it reveals how you are being discredited in the work you do. Yet, ‘we’ must begin doing some introspection of what we are or have been doing, and make necessary...

The New & Improved Fannie Mae “FRAUDULATOR 2.0” Originally known as Fannie Mae’s Collateral Underwriter (CU), and subsequently Collateral Underwriter 2.0 (CU-2)i this always dubious product of Fannie…
Fannie Mae Filed a Complaint Against Me An appraiser shared the following with us which was posted on one of the appraisers’ groups. Fannie Mae filed a…
The Unbiased Reality of Census Tract Data Dump...… Folks, the following letter was sent to FHFA by an appraiser I know. It was sent in response to the…

The post Diatribes Against Appraisers appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

Hybrids vs USPAP Scope of Work Rule

VaCAP Board — Mon, 05 Aug 2019 12:30:13 +0000

Supporters of the bifurcated appraisal can claim scope of work till they are blue in the face… Appraisal Buzz published an article written by Joshua Walit on July 31, 2019 titled Nothing New Under the Sun: The Varied Face of Appraisal. The article brings up some good points, however; it does not take into account the reality of the market and the control of the lenders and appraisal management companies in the process. The mere fact that the appraiser does not have control over the person completing the inspection and in most cases, no way to even know who is providing the...

Desktop Appraisals: Has The Devil Infiltrated The… Are desktop appraisals with third-party inspectors protecting the public, or are these products about to destroy the very profession I…
The New & Improved Fannie Mae “FRAUDULATOR 2.0” Originally known as Fannie Mae’s Collateral Underwriter (CU), and subsequently Collateral Underwriter 2.0 (CU-2)i this always dubious product of Fannie…
The Town With No Bank: How Rural America Lost Its… For decades, we’ve been told that the problem is demand. That people don’t want to live in rural America anymore.…

The post Hybrids vs USPAP Scope of Work Rule appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

Bridging The Gap

Michael Ford — Mon, 23 Apr 2018 12:30:57 +0000

I’m an appraiser. I look at all proposed financial reform legislation in terms of what it does for, or to appraisers. Not whether it was proposed by a red or a blue. Dear AppraisersBlogs readers and fellow appraisers; Anyone who has read my past posts is aware I happen to be a Republican Union Organizer. Usually it isn’t an issue because I try to remain non partisan in my posts and to avoid offensive partisan rhetoric, while promoting appraisers rights; the American Guild of Appraisers, and being critical of bad lending policy and bad appraisal practices. I have also attempted...

The Real Cause of the Home Value Gap Is the Income Gap Blaming appraisers for the income gap will never solve the real underlying problem... Blaming appraisers for the income gap is…
USPAP’s Typical Buyer Standard in the Fair Housing Era The Irreconcilable Conflict Between USPAP's Typical Buyer Standard and the Current Fair Housing Compliance Regime. Retain this document as a…
The Town With No Bank: How Rural America Lost Its… For decades, we’ve been told that the problem is demand. That people don’t want to live in rural America anymore.…

The post Bridging The Gap appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

If I Could Turn Back Time

Guest Author — Wed, 07 Mar 2018 13:30:48 +0000

Community Banks want to bypass appraisals in rural area… Evaluations are the answer, right? There have been lots of discussions lately concerning property inspection waivers, waivers of appraisals in rural areas, and allowing appraisers to complete Evaluations outside of USPAP standards. Doesn’t this all sound familiar? It should, we have already lived it 30 some years ago, prior to FIRREA. Back then Savings and Loans had staff appraisers to complete appraisals. The appraisal was not completed by a licensed appraiser, because licensing to protect the public did not exist. Today Community Banks want to bypass appraisals in rural area. Their...

The New & Improved Fannie Mae “FRAUDULATOR 2.0” Originally known as Fannie Mae’s Collateral Underwriter (CU), and subsequently Collateral Underwriter 2.0 (CU-2)i this always dubious product of Fannie…
Uncovering Flaws in FHA Appraisal & Loan Review Process The story of this single mother's harrowing experience with a defective home purchase and HUD's negligent oversight exposes deep flaws…
Promoting False "Racist Appraiser" Narrative Some Lenders promoting false "racist appraiser" narrative to optimize profits via AVMs Like most businesses lenders want to optimize their…

The post If I Could Turn Back Time appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

Reconsideration of Value Requests

Michael Ford — Mon, 22 Jan 2018 13:30:47 +0000

Open invitation for spurious reconsideration requests… No thank you. I just checked your website and glanced at your “clients” tab, Reconsideration request form. It pretty well negates all the puffed up hyperbole in your email invitation. It is people like you that are the problem, not solutions. Do you think a one of two items drop down menu is an adequate reason for asking an appraiser to reconsider their value? Do you not see a need to request a full and thorough explanation as to why your clients might be asking for a reconsideration? At a minimum didn’t you feel...

The Town With No Bank: How Rural America Lost Its… For decades, we’ve been told that the problem is demand. That people don’t want to live in rural America anymore.…
The Real Cause of the Home Value Gap Is the Income Gap Blaming appraisers for the income gap will never solve the real underlying problem... Blaming appraisers for the income gap is…
Uncovering Flaws in FHA Appraisal & Loan Review Process The story of this single mother's harrowing experience with a defective home purchase and HUD's negligent oversight exposes deep flaws…

The post Reconsideration of Value Requests appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

Smoke Detectors & Appraiser Responsibilities

Michael Ford — Wed, 21 Jun 2017 12:30:46 +0000

Smoke / CO detectors are not “market-measurable” Dear Mr. Lunsford, We have been asked to write to you by an appraiser that just received your most recent communication concerning your new requirements for fee panel appraisers to inspect, photograph and opine as to operability of Carbon Monoxide (CO) and smoke detectors. The American Guild of Appraisers through its affiliated union sponsors represents our own appraiser members as well as the real estate appraisal interests of our combined fraternal families more than thirteen million union members, retirees and their families. We believe this to be an issue of concern for our...

Scope Creep!!! Seems like everyone hates AMC's and scope creep. Scope Creep!! I ordered a sub at a sub shop. I love tomatoes!…
Go Away, Appraisers... “Do they just want us to go away?” Appraisers Feeling Like Travis... Does anyone remember the Pepsi commercial awhile back…
Appraiser's Response to LRES Order Blast LRES Standard Interior Appraisal Request? Your special requirements and micromanagement of the appraisal process dictate that I charge a fee…

The post Smoke Detectors & Appraiser Responsibilities appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

The Partisan Battle to Eliminate Dodd Frank

Michael Ford — Mon, 05 Dec 2016 13:30:38 +0000

Dodd Frank created the illusion… I had a different “take away” from the Housing and Insurance Subcommittee “Modernizing Appraisals” hearing. My impression was that there were two simultaneous hearings by the same people in the same place. There was the actual televised hearing with disparate prepared speeches, and then there was the real underlying reason for the hearing. The partisan battle to eliminate Dodd Frank. I try very hard to take a non partisan approach to the issues facing appraisers when writing about or for the American Guild of Appraisers (AGA). Obviously AGA is a union organization, though as I’ve...

AVMs Can NEVER Replace Appraisals AVMs Can NEVER Replace Appraisals & why FNMAs vaunted CU AVM is flawed! Yesterday (March 15, 2016), an appraiser called…
Freddie Mac Criminal Aspects of Its Appraisal Free Mortgages Freddie Mac is opening itself up to over 150,000± potential individual lawsuits... This is a response from Mike Ford to…
Appraisal Fees ARE Being Manipulated Gas prices in California were $4.25 to $4.50 when oil was last at $100 a barrel. A week ago they were…

The post The Partisan Battle to Eliminate Dodd Frank appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

AMC Indemnification

IDFPR Board — Mon, 31 Oct 2016 12:30:25 +0000

Appraisers signing off catch-all certification… When we crafted the language in the AMC Act back in 2011-2012, we followed what most every other state included insofar as indemnification was concerned. (225 ILCS 459/165) Sec. 165. Prohibited activities. (8) Requiring an appraiser to sign any sort of indemnification agreement that would require the appraiser to defend and hold harmless the appraisal management company or any of its agents, employees, or independent contractors for any liability, damage, losses, or claims arising out of the services performed by the appraisal management company or its agents, employees, or independent contractors and not the services performed...

What Should an Appraiser Do? Burdensome indemnity language required by a lender or AMC Appraisers are often required to sign lengthy contracts to obtain assignments…
What's Wrong with Most Indemnification Clauses in… Objectionable indemnification clauses purport to shift 100% of the liability to individual appraisers... AMC independent contractor agreements are now receiving…
Appraiser's Response to LandSafe Appraisal Appraiser's Response to LandSafe Appraisal Services Agreement In April of 2011, LandSafe Appraisal Services, a wholly owned subsidiary of Bank…

The post AMC Indemnification appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

Appraiser’s Response to LRES Order Blast

Michael Ford — Mon, 25 Jul 2016 12:30:17 +0000

LRES Standard Interior Appraisal Request? Your special requirements and micromanagement of the appraisal process dictate that I charge a fee commensurate with the additional, but typically unnecessary work needed to produce credible results. You are the potential client (agent), so that that is your prerogative and it would be my pleasure to accommodate you as long as appropriate compensation is provided. Respectfully, there is little about your appraisal request that is “standard”. Please explain briefly what you consider to be a ‘standard interior appraisal’. That definition does not appear in The Appraisal Institute’s Dictionary of Real Estate Appraisal. To be...

Requests from Lenders with Specific Statements Lenders' Requests, C&R Fees, Email Blasts, SOW, Unlicensed AMCs and more... What is the best way to ensure you receive…
AMCs Bidding Game An appraiser's response to AMCs bidding system. Recently, we came across an interesting story and thought it's something fruitful that…
Appraisal Fees ARE Being Manipulated Gas prices in California were $4.25 to $4.50 when oil was last at $100 a barrel. A week ago they were…

The post Appraiser’s Response to LRES Order Blast appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

AIR Statement & Revision Requests

John Pratt — Mon, 25 Jan 2016 13:30:41 +0000

AIR Statement & Changes to a Completed Report I would like some of the experts to comment on the following: Scenario Here is a scenario: The lender request that the appraiser include an AIR statement in the completed report. Sometimes they even have a preprinted statement that you must include in the report. The appraiser completes the report and includes the required AIR statement. The AMC reviews the appraisal and send back a revision request. They want comp # 4 removed from the appraisal. Maybe they provide you with another sale that they want you to include in the report....

A Journal Piece of Appraiser Independence A Journal Piece of Appraiser Independence (Part 1): Where Do We Go From Here? Buyer Beware! Where is the Value? (PART…
Appraiser Independence Violated A Journal Piece of Appraiser Independence (Part 2): Appraisal Independence Violated History is an important reminder to us all of…
Letting the AIR Out! After all it's AIR; not a vacuum. First, HVCC is dead. Dead and buried. It died back in 2010. Second,…

The post AIR Statement & Revision Requests appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

The Network Letter RE CU Program

VaCAP Board — Wed, 14 Jan 2015 13:30:12 +0000

Network of State Appraisal Orgainzation’s letter to FHFA Director Watt Regarding Fannie Mae Collateral Underwriter (CU) Program For over the past couple of months, VaCAP has participated with 18 other State Appraiser Coalitions in drafting an unified response to Fannie Mae’s Collateral Underwriter Program. Their letter to FHFA Director Watt briefly outlines their concerns, offers recommended solutions, as well as asking for a meeting to discuss the issue for the benefit of all vested parties. Please take a few minutes to peruse the letter below: Dear Director Watt: On behalf of the independent state professional appraiser organizations signing below, I...

Uncovering Flaws in FHA Appraisal & Loan Review Process The story of this single mother's harrowing experience with a defective home purchase and HUD's negligent oversight exposes deep flaws…
The Town With No Bank: How Rural America Lost Its… For decades, we’ve been told that the problem is demand. That people don’t want to live in rural America anymore.…
It’s Time to Take Out the Junk: AMC Practices Exposed Appraisers have spent years carrying the weight of broken AMC practices, and this article pulls every one of those practices…

The post The Network Letter RE CU Program appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

Agencies AMC Rules Lack Guidance

AppraisersBlogs — Wed, 18 Jun 2014 12:30:12 +0000

Banking Agencies are Told Proposed AMC Rules Fall Short on Guidance In comments filed June 6 with several federal banking agencies, the American Society of Appraisers (ASA) and the National Association of Independent Fee Appraisers expressed our concerns that rules proposed to regulate appraisal management company (AMC) conduct lack sufficient detail to allow for effective implementation. Additionally, the organizations expressed concern that some provisions of the proposed rule depart from Congress’s intent when the enabling law was included in the Dodd-Frank Act, and could negatively affect the overall public policy goals. In the comment letter, ASA and NAIFA cover numerous...

Proposed Rule for AMCs Agencies Issue Proposed Rule on Minimum Requirements for Appraisal Management Companies WASHINGTON — Six agencies today issued a proposed rule…
Federal Register: AMC Final Rule AMC Regulation Rule Finally Published in the Federal Register Appraisers and others, On June 9, 2015, the Federal Register published…
Minimum Requirements for AMCs Proposed Federal Regulation of Appraisal Management Companies (Minimum Requirements for AMCs) I hear a lot from appraisers concerning their interactions…

The post Agencies AMC Rules Lack Guidance appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

Fannie Mae’s Appraiser Quality Monitoring List FAQs

AppraisersBlogs — Mon, 13 Jan 2014 12:30:26 +0000

Appraiser Quality Monitoring Information Fannie Mae has published a new web page with information about the recently implemented Appraiser Quality Monitoring (AQM) process. The new AQM web page includes FAQs and a link to the AQM list identifying appraisers whose appraisals will be subject to 100% review by Fannie Mae or whose appraisals are no longer accepted by Fannie Mae. The AQM list is protected content, and approved Fannie Mae sellers/servicers may set up access through Technology Manager. Appraiser Quality Monitoring (AQM) FAQs Fannie Mae began collecting appraisal data in 2011 through the Uniform Collateral Data Portal® (UCDP®). Millions of...

Is the GSE's "Appraisal Modernization" Really Just… Mass Appraisal tend to exhibit a regressive nature... In the intricate landscape of real estate mortgage financing, the notion of…
Fannie, Freddie's Offshore Gambit Imperils Privacy… The offshore firm will data-mine millions of images showing the personal spaces of U.S. homeowners and tenants. Fearing the Chinese…
Fannie Mae Filed a Complaint Against Me An appraiser shared the following with us which was posted on one of the appraisers’ groups. Fannie Mae filed a…

The post Fannie Mae’s Appraiser Quality Monitoring List FAQs appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

In Response to “Appraisers Under Attack”

AppraisersBlogs — Mon, 26 Aug 2013 12:30:57 +0000

In response to Frank Garay and Brian Steven’s commentary (see video below), on the lawsuit against TriMavin AMC over alleged appraisal independence violations, an anonymous commentator posted the following: There are a number of posters here who need to re-take their CE classes including the moderators. Here are the reasons the entire industry is severely broken. I mean from the Realtor to the Appraiser to the Mortgage Lender. First of all HVCC sunset folks – back in 2010. It was replaced with AIR (Appraiser Independence Regulations) and the Dodd Frank Act. Cannot tell you how irritating it is to me...

The Great Debate on Appraisal Fees She included several different fee split examples indicating AMCs retained as much as 70 percent of the total appraisal fee…
USPAP’s Typical Buyer Standard in the Fair Housing Era The Irreconcilable Conflict Between USPAP's Typical Buyer Standard and the Current Fair Housing Compliance Regime. Retain this document as a…
VA Appraisal Request Form at Heart of AIR Violation… While the statute doesn’t explicitly mention that providing a loan amount is an AIR violation... When a mortgage lender seeks…

The post In Response to “Appraisers Under Attack” appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

Fannie Mae Releases New Selling Guide

AppraisersBlogs — Thu, 23 May 2013 15:45:54 +0000

In April of 2013, Fannie Mae released its updated Selling Guide. "Appraiser Independence Requirements" and "Appraiser Selection" sections were updated...

The New & Improved Fannie Mae “FRAUDULATOR 2.0” Originally known as Fannie Mae’s Collateral Underwriter (CU), and subsequently Collateral Underwriter 2.0 (CU-2)i this always dubious product of Fannie…
Dear Representative, FNMA Has Gone Rogue! Dear representative, waiving/eliminating property appraisal for lending purposes is wanton recklessness. Fannie Mae’s decision to waive/eliminate property appraisal for lending…
It’s Time to Take Out the Junk: AMC Practices Exposed Appraisers have spent years carrying the weight of broken AMC practices, and this article pulls every one of those practices…

The post Fannie Mae Releases New Selling Guide appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

ASA, NAIFA File Comments Regarding Appraisal Complaint Hotline

AppraisersBlogs — Fri, 04 Jan 2013 13:30:00 +0000

The establishment of an appraisal complaint hotline… The American Society of Appraisers (ASA) and the National Association of Independent Fee Appraisers (NAIFA) appreciate the opportunity to jointly comment on the Paperwork Reduction Act implications of the establishment of the Appraisal Complaint Hotline system mandated by section 1473 of Dodd-Frank. Although we understand that the public will have an opportunity to comment on the appraisal complaint form itself when it is proposed (described as “the Interagency Appraisal Complaint Form”), we believe the agencies’ October 22nd Federal Register request for comment provides our organizations (and other stakeholders) with an important opportunity to...

Top DEI Bosses Have a Problem - Diversity The ranks of the new DEI bosses at the financial institutions are no more diverse than the appraisers their institutions…
The Town With No Bank: How Rural America Lost Its… For decades, we’ve been told that the problem is demand. That people don’t want to live in rural America anymore.…
It’s Time to Take Out the Junk: AMC Practices Exposed Appraisers have spent years carrying the weight of broken AMC practices, and this article pulls every one of those practices…

The post ASA, NAIFA File Comments Regarding Appraisal Complaint Hotline appeared on Appraisers Blogs.

Appraiser Independence Requirements - Appraisers Blogs

Appraiser Independence: What Does it Mean & Who Does it Apply to

Related Posts:

Appraisers Pressured to Inflate Values Based on Race

Related Posts:

VA Appraisal Request Form at Heart of AIR Violation Class Action

Related Posts:

Fastapp AMC Alleged Violations of AIR

Related Posts:

Diatribes Against Appraisers

Related Posts:

Hybrids vs USPAP Scope of Work Rule

Related Posts:

Bridging The Gap

Related Posts:

If I Could Turn Back Time

Related Posts:

Reconsideration of Value Requests

Related Posts:

Smoke Detectors & Appraiser Responsibilities

Related Posts:

The Partisan Battle to Eliminate Dodd Frank

Related Posts:

AMC Indemnification

Related Posts:

Appraiser’s Response to LRES Order Blast

Related Posts:

AIR Statement & Revision Requests

Related Posts:

The Network Letter RE CU Program

Related Posts:

Agencies AMC Rules Lack Guidance

Related Posts:

Fannie Mae’s Appraiser Quality Monitoring List FAQs

Related Posts:

In Response to “Appraisers Under Attack”

Related Posts:

Fannie Mae Releases New Selling Guide

Related Posts:

ASA, NAIFA File Comments Regarding Appraisal Complaint Hotline

Related Posts: